Thursday, September 25, 2008

Review: Anana In Damascus

NOTE: This post was written a few days ago.

It seems one of our fellow Iraqi bloggers is generating something of a buzz, but in the Arab media for a change. Artist and blogger Sundus Abdilhadi made headlines in Elaph, and later tonight in al-Arabiya.net's website for her controversial painting "Inana in Damascus", which depicts a naked Iraqi woman standing in a crowd outside a nightclub called 'Al-Hirmann' (loose translation, Deprivation), the crowd includes a man in a Gulf attire who appears to be petting her, and also an American soldier who watches nonchalantly.

Now that I've finished reporting, let me have my own analysis of the painting, I'm a total layman in regards to paintings (especially ones in the style of Miss Abdulhadi) and I can never get why so-and-so is supposed to be great, but I'm the sort of the guy who likes to think of every work of art as having more than mere face value, details that reveal themselves with each repeated look or listen.

The painting is based on an Orientalist painting called the "Slave Market" by Jean-Pierre Gerome:


I recounted somewhere in this blog that I used to try to incorporate some Pan-Arab resistance motifs in my imaginary heavy metal shows, I didn't really believe in any of it, and the only reason I did so is because I wanted to be heard and get famous, in another word, I was being exploitative. This painting can be held with a similar accusation, all it did was cast the crowd with the appropriate roles, an American soldier being forced in for good measure, and there you go.

However, a more in-depth view reveals several details that in my opinion clears Abdulhadi of that crime, while Gerome's painting seems to be concerned more with painting just for the sake of painting, in regards to the subject matter, it is completely neutral, the painting does not say anything other than brillianly recreating the incident it is portraying, life is frozen appropreitely in majesty and as always the painting celebrates the female body and lighting is made to reflect that.

Abdulhadi's version is quite different, its main objective is not painting per se, but commentary, heavy depression prevades the entire picture and girl's body is unimportant, what's important is the hypocrisy implied in the addition of the far-away minarets, or the supposed dignity and valor in the attire of the Gulf man, or the leering guy in the background, however the US soldier does sound forced, and America's invovlement should have been incorporated some other way, the impact is made more significant when one looks at the Gerome and realizes the concept of men gathering around a naked woman illustrates the fact that women are still treated more or less as sex-objects 150 years later. Moreover, Abdulhadi's style renders the entire populace in a primitive, inhuman allure that strips humanity away and shows them as the vassals for ideas they're supposed to be.
Having said that, this explicit commentary still hurt the painting as a work of art, I would gladly hang the first in my living room and look at it every other Friday, but this one is just too political and too obvious to be touching in any meaningful way. It is indeed hard to be creative and find a genuinely original portrayal of the devastation of war and the hypocrisy of men, and because there is no high-resolution version of the painting anywhere online, I couldn't really examine it as closely as I wanted. But the added ideas and detail does suggest that Miss Abdulhadi has the potential to surprise us with something in her future attempts. (and for the record, this is my least favorite of her paintings, you should check out her blog for that, the title of her blog looks great)

7 comments:

Shams said...

I can definitely see Sundus message, especially with the Gulf hypocrisy of being overly religious, yet they do other things -otherwise- outside their country.
However I think her critique is lacking, there is No Criticism of Iraq Men's responsibility in the whole ordeal, she says the men who meant to support such ladies are dead/killed, yet where is our government???? Why the hell their families are still in the west, getting the best of education and leading secure lives, while other Iraqis have to live in such miserable ways... and how about Iran, why only Arabs and America to be blamed.

She is an artist after all, not a political analyst, I do see the message but it is somehow a redundant theme of cliches of how people perceive especially gulf men.

nadia said...

I thought the depiction of the buyer was a much more direct reference to the a large part of the clientele of the clubs where prostitution takes place being from the Gulf/Saudi, more than it was an abstract comment on Arab hypocrisy.

I don't know if that is actually the case or not but it seems to be a widely held perception.

nadia said...

Anyways, to help you play art critic if you were going to read more into the imagery I would look into her choice of imitating an orientalist painting, which was I think very deliberate. French guy may not have had what he considered a conscious agenda, but people today look at his stuff as part and parcel of the mentality of the time..and if you think about what the popular ideas were in Europe at that time then you might have a better idea of what she had in mind with her choice of subjects.

onix said...

its a traditional style in art if u need to achieve a contemporain message to overdo and old but telling work of art.
That besides i like the original better, is see no sane reason to deny the beauty of the female body.
personally i prefer the original as a piece of art, you are very right that it is extremely difficult to depict a serious subject in art.

Anonymous said...

Sundus,

Fuck man, you can't even paint! Jeezus, it looks like an 8-year-old painted your additions.

Whew! What crap! And then like a blowhard asshole you have the nerve to go on with all that phony orientalism shite. Fucking hell. More nonsense.

*

Unknown said...

2015-11-4leilei
michael kors handbags
coach outlet online
louis vuitton handbags
coach factory outlet
hollister uk
canada goose uk
nike roshe run
nike sb dunks
kate spade
coach outlet online
jordan 3 retro
ralph lauren outlet
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet
pandora charms
michael kors outlet
kate spade handbags
fitflop shoes
ugg boots
cheap jordan shoes
retro jordans 13
coach outlet online
coach factory outlet online
michael kors outlet
prada handbags
michael kors handbags
toms shoes
louis vuitton outlet onlne
jordan retro 4
nike store
ugg boots australia
michael kors handbags
coach factory outlet
north face uk
louis vuitton

Unknown said...

oracle finance functional r12 is the online training course in 128 kB of memory. Oracle Finance Functional (R12) Online TrainingImplementation separates Oracle code from user code. Oracle V1 is never officially released