Tuesday, August 05, 2008

A Sectarian Analysis of Yassir al-Habib's TOEFL Score

This is very surprising, in fact shocking, because usually most men of religion, especially ones raised in their native homelands (Kuwait, in this case, although he speaks with an Iraqi dialect), are often stereotyped as rather illiterate in virtually every other field of knowledge. Sheikh Yassir al-Habib, a notorious YouTube Shi'i young cleric, employs English masterfully in this YouTube series to explain a (disputed) Shi'i view that Prophet Muhammed did not die a natural death, but was assassinated by his wives Aisha (at his time of death, she had just hit 18 btw) & Hafsa, the daughters of two of Shia Islam's Supervillians/Sunni Islam's Heroes (not exactly superheroes, Sunni Islam is boring): first two caliphs Abu Bakr "Blueye" Bin Quhafa and Umar "Ribbreaker" Bin al-Khattab .
It has been taken for granted that for countless centuries, the Shia were the oppressed and the Sunni were the oppressors, however, this doesn't necessarily indicate that the Shia are anymore peaceful or tolerant than the Sunnis in any way, they simply lost the power struggle, and facing the fact of being sore losers, they settled for a vindictive agenda that was put on hold until future Terminator-Mahdi activates World Shutdown Sequence, while the Sunnis happily chopped off their heads and have rather enjoyed their sadistic tenure in power (as opposed to the Shi'i masochistic self-sacrifice) until they were put in the Losing Shi'i position of the food chain at large by the West when Napoleon washed up Egypt's shore. In fact, a world where Shia make up 90% of the Muslim world would find the Umayyad-following, Nasibi Holy-Imam-Killing sect of Sunnism in a very difficult environment that might force them to adopt many of the evasive measurements now unique to Shi'ism.
But enough What-Ifs, being only 10-15%, the Shia found no other option but to hit the mattresses and be implicit about their own takfirist impulses. This finds itself true in many manifestations, especially when comparing the accomodative role of the Shia minority in Syria and the suppressive role of the Sunni minority in Iraq, (coming up in a future post).

Because of all of this, Sheikh Yassir al-Habib is an interesting figure, he is a young cleric who has quickly gained notoriety, attained quickly by bombast and controversy, unlike virtually all Shi'is, he publicly blasphemes the companions harshly and explicitly, for which he was imprisoned in Kuwait, only to manage to seek asylum and resettle in the United Kingdom, the man is a recurring figure in many discussion forums and video sites, you might him remember as the guy who actively called for the burning and destruction of Sunni mosques following the Askariya 2006 events (although that video was edited for effect), in many ways, the extremism of his views are equivalent of the Wahhabi 'Takfiri' sheikhs who are murderously opposed to the Rafidha Shia, a class that usually summons Ibn Taymiyya alongside modern stalwarts such as Ibn Baz, Ibn Jibreen, and Salih al-Fawzan. But the rarity of extremist figures on the Shi'i side is only a matter of the careful prudent hate of the traditional Shi'i system, produced by centuries of a their perception of being oppressed. In defiance, Yassir courageously describes the Sunnis as 'unbelievers', he also complains that the Askari shrine is under the control of the 'Nawasib' (lit. Ali-haters, but here he means the Iraqi Sunni endowment) and the priority of its reclamation is more important than reclaiming Jerusalem, in fact, his default word for 'Sunnism' in this video is a dismissive 'Bakri sect'. Listening to his lectures, the whole Shi'i thing seems to be concetrated at getting sweet revenge from Umar.
So we come to ask the big question again, often asked by the larger West vis-a-vis the smaller Islam in the food chain, is this Yassir al-Haibi guy an extremist nonsensical offshoot who wants to make it big quick or are there some concrete facts that supplied this hatred and he's just being honest about it? Well, for most of the time, Sunni-Shia relations were lukewarm at best, and they only come into unison when faced by a common enemy, such as Abu Naji** in 1920s Iraq (although the intents of the various factions in that revolution comes into heavy dispute), or the general lack of interest in religion in the 60s, heydays of Pan-Arab Nasserism, which was a time when the Arab Socialist Ba'ath Party would hold demonstrations in tandem with al-Hakim family against Qasim's Communists, and most spectacularly a fatwa validating the Shi'i sect by the highest Sunni authority, Egyptian al-Azhar (which, interestingly, was built by Fatimid Shia), although the Azhar hurridely distanced itself from the fatwa as time progressed and the Iranian revolution burst upon the panicked Gulf and the shit-ruined America, who both hurried to Saddam. Other than these circumstantial periods, the constant assurance that 'everything is all right' and 'we are only different by 20% or less' is made more worrying with the number of the dead piling up and the increase in extremist hysteria from both sides of the camp, all signs of a very strained hostility that is constantly emerging after being buried not-so-subtly in history books. with the Sunnis naturally being the more outspoken considering their size , their traditional dominance and their perceived loss of power. That's the only difference, as evidenced by the concentrated dose of honest hate of al-Habib as lashed out in this reactionary fashion. In this environment, which lacks any understanding of meaningful coexistence, Prophet Bush's shock-and-awe democracy won't work, so here's hoping for another miracle, (although not one as my otherwise-nice uncle suggests: nuke all the Shia.) :)


** Abu Naji = An Iraqi slang for British, what, you think your 'Haji' is original?

24 comments:

Lynnette In Minnesota said...

** Abu Naji = An Iraqi slang for British, what, you think your 'Haji' is original?

lol! So much for all those people who made such a big deal about the term "Haji".

Interesting post, Abbas.

In this environment, which lacks any understanding of meaningful coexistence, Prophet Bush's shock-and-awe democracy won't work, so here's hoping for another miracle, (although not one as my otherwise-nice uncle suggests: nuke all the Shia.) :)

I know it seems impossible. But the thing though, Abbas, is that there are so many parallels between the creation of our country and the attempt to re-make Iraq into a democratic type of country. You aren't the first ones to thrive on conspiracy theories or to have competing factions that seem to want to tear your country apart. And we still had Great Britain, Spain and France to deal with, just as you have Iran, Turkey and Syria.

But you have far more history to deal with then did we. We also had more of a predisposition to handling things on our own. Great Britain was so far away for day to day governance, we had little choice. The history of the ME in general is rife with one party conquering another and her people being ruled by a strongman or dictator. That doesn't prepare you very well for a democracy.

As one historian put it, the United States revolution was a struggle for the rights of man. It was not a struggle for a religion or a king, but a fight for individual rights. And we have been fighting for those things ever since 1776.

You need to find a reason for unity other than a common enemy. That is an ephemeral reason to unite.

Considering the obstacles we have overcome, some people might say that the creation and continued existence of the United States is a miracle. I hope Iraq can also find one.

Btw, I finished "The Glorious Cause" (as if you couldn't tell ;)). It was very good and filled in a number of holes in my knowledge of our revolution. I know you will probably not read it, but it is a good place to start to find out more about the United States.

ahmed said...

Lynette,

the point of posts such as these is to dispel those people who pretend that Sunnis and Shia have no problems with each other and that it's all a political struggle, while the common folks surely all want to live and let live, they still are filled with a sizable notion of religious animosity that fuels those political-religious divisions. So far, I see that in the long-term the only plausible option to end this conflict and to mend Iraq into a definable 'country' is the complete obliteration of religion. How to go about that is an incredible mission, but I think we first need to define why is there no other way but this.

nadia said...

Man that is catchy


*runs and hides*

Lynnette In Minnesota said...

Abbas,

the point of posts such as these is to dispel those people who pretend that Sunnis and Shia have no problems with each other and that it's all a political struggle

Yes, I know what you are trying to say. I have perhaps been commenting poorly. What I have been trying to get across is that there have been times when other countries (and I have been using the US as an example) have struggled with differences that seemed insurmountable. Perhaps a better example would have been the troubles in Northern Ireland, as they were more religion based.

So far, I see that in the long-term the only plausible option to end this conflict and to mend Iraq into a definable 'country' is the complete obliteration of religion.

Don't you think that a little extreme? And is it really religion per se that is the problem? Or is it the intolerance that man shows to his fellow man?

As I have said in the past I am a supporter of the separation of religion and state. I think any policy that will encourage a fair shake for all is imperative. And that means allowing people to be who they will, as long as they bring no harm to others.

Shams said...

I think the problem is with the religious history, it seems sunnis and shias have two opposing historical anecdotes. It is either secularism from below to top or clergy understanding and forgiveness from top to bottom, though i favor the former.

Sometimes religion cease to be religion as it is filled with human characters, so worldly, I hope Islam to filter such worldly politics and maybe concentrate on spirituality and self-betterment, but that needs enlightenment, freedom and unbiased history books.

Anonymous said...

Good post Abbas, my view might be schewed since I am a Sunni but I hear a lot of these Shii folk talk about "Takfeer", the "Wahhabis", "Salafis" and what have you and not a word is spoken about the likes of Habib and many more "Takfeeris" who are only hiding their colours under the veil of "Takia". In my view, Sunnism and Shiism can coexist but only after all manifestations of Political Islam - a la "Wilayat Al Fakeeh" and the "Khilafah - are banished forever. Failing that, I would suggest forcefully converting everyone to Suffism, the true face of peaceful, spiritual Islam that spreads love and piety!! :-D

Anonymous said...

Hi it's me, I am also visiting this website daily, this website is actually fastidious and the viewers are genuinely sharing fastidious thoughts.

Here is my page payday loans

Anonymous said...

Cаn you tell us morе about this? I'd care to find out more details.

Here is my weblog payday loans

Anonymous said...

wonderful post, very informative. I wonder why the opposite experts of this sector
don't understand this. You must continue your writing.
I'm confident, you have a great readers' base already!


My web blog - how to trimmer line ryobi

Anonymous said...

This is always to prevent any damage from occurring for the DVD drive or
even the laptop. If a laptop shows a challenge, before opting to buy motherboard,
you ought to search for a professional which has experts to correct laptops.


It have to be compelling enough to keep the reader wanting more.
It is something was true in opposition towards the blacks in the period of
slavery and remains to a degree true.
seriously asus vivobook x200ca 11.6 touchscreen l\u003cb\u003eaptop review To comprehend this, consider yourself status within
an area enclosed by three buddies who will be getting an image person.
Teaching children to weave occasional figurative language inside their stories will
help their descriptive writing become stronger.

Anonymous said...

I couldn't refrain from commenting. Perfectly written!



my web-site :: jeux mmorpg gratuit

Anonymous said...

Wow, this article is fastidious, my younger sister is analyzing such
things, so I am going to tell her.

Visit my page weight loss programs

Anonymous said...

Hello, everything is going nicely here and ofcourse every one is sharing facts, that's
really good, keep up writing.

Also visit my webpage; how to increase seminal volume [gohealthforlife.com]

Anonymous said...

The duty is when you yourself have to seek
out videos which are from different places.
This really is one of many wit packed movies and a necessity watch for the Jim
Carey fans!

Here is my page :: movie2k (comunidade.3dcenter.com.br)

Anonymous said...

I read this post fully regarding the resemblance of hottest and preceding
technologies, it's amazing article.

Take a look at my homepage; girlfriend activation system ripoff

Anonymous said...

Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins
to protect against hackers? I'm kinda paranoid about losing everything
I've worked hard on. Any tips?

My web site: como hackear un facebook ()

Anonymous said...

Gifts: Each Day you can send and receive gifts
with your friends. And suddenly, people looked to
the king for a performance that would emotionally connect.
In terms of where the content of the therapy scenes, really,
that comes out of David Seidler's imagination.

My weblog: throne rush hack ()

Anonymous said...

electronic cigarette starter kit, electronic cigarette reviews, e cigarette, electronic cigarette starter kit, electronic cigarettes, electronic cigarettes

Unknown said...

2015627dongdong
hollister
christian louboutin
pandora charms
michael kors outlet
abercrombie outlet
gucci shoes
oakley sunglasses wholesale
oakley sunglasses outlet
hermes
jordan 11 concord
lululemon
michael kors outlet
football shoes
longchamp outlet
louis vuitton outlet
abercrombie
oakley sunglasses
fitflops clearance
gucci outlet
oakley sunglass
kevin durant shoes
christian louboutin
burberry outlet
oakley sunglass
nike air max
louis vuitton uk
michael kors outlet
ray bans
tory burch outlet
ed hardy clothing
polo ralph lauren
ralph lauren sale
hollister clothing
ray ban sunglasses
louis vuitton
michael kors handbags
hollister clothing
christian louboutin
michael kors outlet
pandora charms

Unknown said...

15.07.24daigege
gucci
cheap ray ban sunglasses
oakley store
ray bans
cheap jordans
gucci outlet
michael kors handbag
kate spade handbags
chanel bags
michael kors
oakley sunglasses discount
mcm outlet
coach outlet store online
tory burch outlet online
oakley sunglasses
ray ban uk
pandora outlet
air max shoes
replica watches
cheap ray ban sunglasses
pandora charms 2015
abercrombie
fitflops sale clearance
fitflops outlet
jordan homme
michael kors outlet
chanel outlet
nike blazer
jordan pas cher
michael kors
ed hardy clothing
ray ban sunglasses
christian louboutin outlet
kate spade outlet
soccer shoes
true religion outlet
longchamp pas cher
kate spade uk
replica watches cheap
oakley online

bhdfszjde said...

Ultrasound Sensor
Spo2Sensor
Ultrasound Sensor
Spo2 Sensor

wholesale nfl jerseys said...

Welcome action against Jaish e 3d vr glassesMohammad as positive first step by Pak: MEAAmit Shah celebrates Makar SankrantiForeign secretary level talks virtual reality glasseswith Pakistan put on holdWreath laying ceremony of 1971 war hero Lt Gen JFR JacobPilgrims take holy dip on Makar SankrantiNot aware vr headsetof protective custody of Masood Azhar: Pak govtCreate Your Own AdAdvertise with usFeedbackTOI Mobilevr headset

Unknown said...

sas bi online training cloud computing research project,SAS BI Online Training
around the time the term started gaining popularity in the mainstream press. It was a hot topic by mid-2008 and numerous cloud computing events had been scheduled

Unknown said...

adidas neo
lebron 13
michael kors outlet
links of london outlet store
adidas online shop
nike air huarache
adidas yeezy boost
michael kors outlet online
michael kors
adidas stan smith
20170616